In most of the obituaries of Joan Fontaine, the acclaimed actress who died last Sunday in Carmel, Calif. at 96, if her starring role with Harry Belafonte is mentioned at all it will be an afterthought. That may be perfectly all right since the film Island in the Sun, cannot rank among her best performances, particularly when compared to her Oscar winning role in Suspicion.
But among African American filmgoersand some white ones with racist inclinationsFontaine is remembered for co-starring as Belafontes lover, however unrequited their romantic overtures.
The film, according to historian Donald Bogle, is marred by compromises. Because of its theme of miscegenation, he writes, Island in the Sun, was controversial even during the shooting. Bogles focus here is on Dorothy Dandridge, the famed Black actress who is paired with white actor John Justin. This is 1957, only three years after Brown v. the Board of Education, and any lovemaking on the screen between mixed couples was taboo, especially for theater owners in the South.
At least Dandridge and Justin are seen holding hands and dancing, which is about as close as they get to consummating their romance; Belafonte and Fontaine, except for furtive glances, dont even get this far, though Belafonte ingeniously finds a way to deliver a subtle kiss to his co-star.
In the evenings, after acting all day, Belafonte and Fontaine began to think of ways to subvert the film, to convey their highly restricted feelings. We had another romantic scene the next day, Belafonte recalled in his memoir My Song, after another frustrating day on the set. In this one, I was to slice open a coconut with a machete and offer it to Joan so she could sample the milk inside.
What I did the next day was hand it to her and watch, intensely as she drank, he continued. Then I took it back, my eyes on the place where shed put her lips. Slowly and deliberately, I put my lips where hers had been. Then I took the sip that consummated the moment. For anyone who followed it carefully enough, the scene would have, in its own way, a passionate climax.
Belafontes memoir contains more interesting comments on the film, both on and off camera, and for that youll have to get the book. It might be good to know how Fontaine felt about all this since she tended to speak very openly about things, including the contentious relationship with her equally talented sister, Olivia De Haviland.
If possible, get a copy of Fontaines autobiography, No Bed of Roses, and perhaps she offers there some further insight on her relationship with Belafonte. During an interview with People magazine in 1978, she discusses many of the men she romanced on film as well as her four husbands. Nothing was said there about Belafonte.