List Of 10 Most Collectible Football Cards: Top Cards That Must Be on Every Collector’s Radar

Published March 4, 2025 by Mary Brown
Sports
Featured image for List Of 10 Most Collectible Football Cards: Top Cards That Must Be on Every Collector’s Radar

Football card collection is one of the most cherished hobbies for the majority of Americans who love the sport. The origin of football cards dates back to centuries with the first card produced in the 1800s. The thrill of discovering a new and rare card is definitely unmatched. Some of such rare cards have transformed into a prized possession for whoever holds them. If you want to know the top 10 such cards that are a must-have in your collection, this article is for you. It brings you a list of 10 most collectible football cards. The following article also explores the features that make these cards unique. 

1958 Jim Brown Rookie Card

1958 Jim Brown Rookie Card

The 1958 Jim Brown Rookie Card is one of the most valuable football cards worth $358,500. The card is extremely famous among the collectors and features the football legend in the early years of his career. PSA has officially authenticated the card. Only 5 of Jim Brown’s Rookie Cards have a professional grade as high as 9. This makes the card even more valuable.

1976 Walter Payton Rookie Card

1976 Walter Payton Rookie Card

The 1976 Walter Payton rookie Card is another one of the most sought-after cards worth $124,230. The card is often sold for $100,000 when it’s in its best condition. An unspoiled old card is already hard to get. Moreover, if the card is one of the greatest running backs in the history of football, it increases the value tenfold.

Also read: 2026 Toyota RAV4 Redesign: What’s New in Toyota’s Best SUV?

1965 Topps Joe Namath Rookie Card 

The 1965 Topps Joe Namath Rookie Card also earned a place in our list of the top 10 most collectible football cards. The card is currently worth $264,000. Joe Namath was one of the most popular football legends of his time. His rookie card is extremely rare and hard to find. Only 5 of his rookie cards have received a condition grading of 9 or above.

2000 Tom Brady Autographed Rookie Card

Tom Brady is considered one of the biggest names in the football landscape in the current generation. Therefore, it is not a surprise that his 2000 Tom Brady Autographed Rookie Card is worth $2.4 million. The 200 Playoff Contenders Championship Ticket rookie card is currently one of the most valuable cards you must have in your collection.

1957 Bart Starr Rookie Card

The 1957 Bart Starr Rookie Card is often considered one of the oldest cards that still hold immense value for collectors. It is currently worth $288,000. A Bart Starr rookie card which is in good condition is rare but not hard to find. It will definitely be a great addition to your collection.

1981 Joe Montana Rookie Card

The 1981 Joe Montana Rookie Card is also one of the most sought-after football cards worth $87,000. Joe Montana is known as one of the most popular and successful quarterbacks in history. His 1981 rookie cards are hard to find in good condition. So, if you find one for your collection you definitely win in life.

1935 Bronko Nagurski Rookie Card 

The 1935 Bronko Nagurski Rookie Card is considered the oldest football card to ever exist. Therefore, it is pretty obvious that it is bound to appear in the list of the 10 most collectible football cards. The card is currently worth $174,000. Bronko Nagurski was a legendary linebacker and fullback. This makes his rookie card even more valuable.

1971 Terry Bradshaw Rookie Card

The 1971 Terry Bradshaw Rookie Card is also one of the most popular ones among the collectors. The card is currently worth $430,500 and it was the only kind of card produced for his rookie year. Only 110 cards received the gem mint 10 grade making it a valuable addition to your collection.

2005 Aaron Rodgers Shield Patch Card

The 2005 Aaron Rodgers Shield Patch Card is considered one of the rarest football cards worth $229,200. This is because of various reasons. It is a one-of-a-kind footfall card and represents the debut year of Aaron Rodgers. However, this is not the best part. The best part of the card is that it contains a patch from his jersey along with a 10-quality autograph. 

2017 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card

The 2017 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card is considered one of the most expensive football cards worth $4.3 million. This card is also one of a kind and includes a patch of his jersey. It also has an 8.5 grade autograph making it extremely rare.

Share Post:
M

Mary Brown