How Much Would a Payroll Tax Cut Add to Your Paycheck? Philly Accountants Lay it Out

If Congress passes an emergency payroll tax cut, how much would it add to your weekly paycheck?

Take your salary and deduct 2% — that’s your tax savings. If you earn $50,000 a year, and get a 2% payroll tax cut — that’s about $1,000, or one week’s wages.

The cost of a payroll tax cut or holiday would depend on how much of the tax is rolled back and for how long. A 2% cut for employees, as President Barack Obama did, cost $150 billion in government revenue over a year and $300 billion if the employer portion had also been cut, according to Bloomberg data.

Today’s payroll tax rate is 15.3%, with 12.4% of that going to fund Social Security and 2.9% to fund Medicare.

Social Security’s 12.4% portion taxes up to $137,700 of wages in 2020, split evenly between workers and employers. The Medicare payroll tax is 2.9% on all wages, split evenly between workers and employers, plus 0.9% more on top earners.

Michael Gillen, director of the tax accounting group at Duane Morris, broke down the Social Security payroll tax: “The Social Security portion of the payroll tax is imposed on earnings up to an annual maximum of $137,700, while the Medicare share of the tax applies to all employee earnings without limit. Then, there is an additional 0.9% Medicare tax levied on all earnings above $200,000. Only employees bear this additional tax.”

He thinks a temporary payroll tax could emerge as part of a rescue package that includes aid to hotels, cruise ships and airlines, and the U.S. oil and gas industry.

“If we use the past as an indicator, back in 2011, there was a 2% cut on the employee side. So, instead of paying in at 6.2% for Social Security taxes, contributions were 4.2% for Social Security taxes up to the cap,” he said. Contributions for Medicare remained the same.

With a similar payroll tax cut now, top wage earners could save up to $2,754 ($137,700 x 2%), he estimated. For those near the poverty level, however, the tax savings could be minimal.

Although the tax savings might not amount to a lot of money, “this would be a psychological move, for sure,” said Blue Bell, Pa.-based accountant David Zalles.

Tax season

Will COVID19 delay tax filing season? Yes. The U.S. Treasury on Wednesday confirmed it will push back the April 15 filing deadline.

Mitchell Gerstein, senior tax adviser with Isdaner & Co. in Bala Cynwyd, Pa., said the IRS often does extend filing deadlines in federal disaster areas, he said, though not generally when states declare emergencies, such as Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

“One of our clients has decided to wait it out at her cabin in the woods,” said Gerstein. “That’s one extreme. The other is that many of us are working from home and using technology such as FaceTime for client meetings.”

He believes a tax credit might be a better panacea for the outbreak.

Others, such as Jim Cramer, host of CNBC’s Mad Money, now in its 15th year, don’t want a payroll tax holiday and instead advocate for paid sick leave and no- or low-interest loans for small businesses affected by the economic slowdown.

“Americans don’t want a payroll tax cut. That only works if you’re still on a payroll,” he said. Instead, small businesses need the relief to not have to lay off workers until COVID is contained, Cramer said.


(Article written by Erin Arvedlund)